Bullet Length
5 posters
WELCOME to High Plains Muzzle Loading Forum! :: Muzzleloading, Firearms & Optics :: Long Range Hunting & Target Shooting
Page 1 of 1
Bullet Length
Ok, finally got moved and casting equipment set up, somewhat.
What bullet length is working best in the 48 twist TC for long range?
What bullet length is working best in the 48 twist TC for long range?
Pvt.Jack- Posts : 8
Join date : 2022-03-06
squattingdog likes this post
Re: Bullet Length
It’s a .50 cal, BTW.
Pvt.Jack- Posts : 8
Join date : 2022-03-06
squattingdog likes this post
Re: Bullet Length
Acceptable bullet length is not only dependent on rifling twist rate. The bullet balance point has much to do with in flight stability. A bullet can be stabilized in two ways . The most commonly referred to is spin. Spin or rotational velocity must increase as the projectile length increases to keep a bullet stable in flight. More bullet = more spin .
Ther is also another way to stabilize a bullet which is known as form stability. Form stability addresses the balance point of the bullet putting most of the weight forward such as in a Foster slug fired in a smooth bore. The nose heavy balance
keeps the bullet flying nose forward with no spin/rotational velocity.
If you combine spin with form you can get quite good accuracy with a bullet length far longer than what the Greenhill formula might predict. This is not new news as form and spin was combined in rifles and projectile put to quite accurate long range use in our first American uncivil war.
Ther is also another way to stabilize a bullet which is known as form stability. Form stability addresses the balance point of the bullet putting most of the weight forward such as in a Foster slug fired in a smooth bore. The nose heavy balance
keeps the bullet flying nose forward with no spin/rotational velocity.
If you combine spin with form you can get quite good accuracy with a bullet length far longer than what the Greenhill formula might predict. This is not new news as form and spin was combined in rifles and projectile put to quite accurate long range use in our first American uncivil war.
bullshop- Posts : 51
Join date : 2021-12-30
Rustycorvair likes this post
Re: Bullet Length
Thanks for that response.
I got an adjustable mold, so lots of experimentation forth coming.
I got an adjustable mold, so lots of experimentation forth coming.
Pvt.Jack- Posts : 8
Join date : 2022-03-06
Re: Bullet Length
There is another form a stability I didnt mention because it really will not apply to our purpose and that is fin stability as with an arrow. I guess if you were to load a big bore smooth bore with a load of fletchetts or an arrow it could apply. I just mention it for those that just knew I was wrong when I said there were two ways.
bullshop- Posts : 51
Join date : 2021-12-30
Re: Bullet Length
Bullshop, could you fire a foster slug out of a round ball slow twist barrel and maintain accuracy???
EasternOregon .50cal GPR- Posts : 93
Join date : 2021-12-05
Age : 33
Re: Bullet Length
My 48 twists seem to like big lead like my 54 especially. the 50 as well. I have a 50 cal i bullet mold from accurate molds. The 50 bullet drops 450gr and the one for the 54 weighs 515gr both shoot great for me. I ordered mine .002” over bore diameter and don’t have any issues loading and I don’t have to size them either, good luck, these are just what mine like, my 54 doesn’t shoot round balls worth a darn no matter what I do, can’t say if the 50 does I’ll play with that some more but it likes the 450gr bullet in the 48 twist barrel
Ivan Wagurak- Posts : 199
Join date : 2021-12-01
Age : 46
Location : Maine
EasternOregon .50cal GPR likes this post
Re: Bullet Length
Using The Greenhill method, the longest length for a 1:48 twist in a .50 is .78" long, so very slightly over 3/4 of an inch. The Greenhill method is still used for lead and lead alloys. There is another method (Miller Twist Rule) used for jacketed bullets and allowing for different bullet shapes.
This only works for pure lead, and everything is done in inches. For alloys, there is another part of the equation required to find the density ratio of lead to the alloy, taking the result and finding its square root.
Also, the amount of bearing surface engaged into the grooves makes a difference. If a bullet is mostly grease grooves, it may plow through the rifling. There isn't enough lead making full contact in the grooves.
Bullet size = .50 squared
Multiply the answer above by 150
Take that answer, and divide it by the bullet length.
.50 x .50 = .250 (same as .50 squared)
.250 x 150 = 37.5
37.5 / .78 (bullet length) = 48" (twist rate of 1:48)
This only works for pure lead, and everything is done in inches. For alloys, there is another part of the equation required to find the density ratio of lead to the alloy, taking the result and finding its square root.
Also, the amount of bearing surface engaged into the grooves makes a difference. If a bullet is mostly grease grooves, it may plow through the rifling. There isn't enough lead making full contact in the grooves.
Bullet size = .50 squared
Multiply the answer above by 150
Take that answer, and divide it by the bullet length.
.50 x .50 = .250 (same as .50 squared)
.250 x 150 = 37.5
37.5 / .78 (bullet length) = 48" (twist rate of 1:48)
drpatton- Posts : 3
Join date : 2022-11-18
Ivan Wagurak and Grant Northcott like this post
Similar topics
» October Country percussion rifle, .58 caliber, 1/72 twist, 36" length barrel
» What Bullet To Go With
» The "I" bullet
» Bullet type
» Bullet mold not filling out
» What Bullet To Go With
» The "I" bullet
» Bullet type
» Bullet mold not filling out
WELCOME to High Plains Muzzle Loading Forum! :: Muzzleloading, Firearms & Optics :: Long Range Hunting & Target Shooting
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum