Alloy or pure lead
3 posters
WELCOME to Idaho Lewis’s Muzzleloading Forum :: Muzzleloading, Firearms & Optics :: Black Powder Pistols
Page 1 of 1
Alloy or pure lead
I'm looking at a mould for both my 45 ACP and should I ever get a 44 BP revolver. The mould is the Lee 90351 which is a .452" 228 gr round nose. My question is do I need a pure lead for the revolver and an alloyed one for the 45 ACP. Or another way to put it - can I shoot a harder bullet out of the BP revolver?
Another option is to cast pure lead then lube the bullets for the revolver and powder coat the ones for the 45 ACP.
Thoughts and advice please.
Another option is to cast pure lead then lube the bullets for the revolver and powder coat the ones for the 45 ACP.
Thoughts and advice please.
_________________
I am not in competition with anyone and have no desire to be better than anyone else. I simply try to be a better person today than I was yesterday.
PRAYER SHOULD BE YOUR FIRST RESPONSE - NOT YOUR LAST RESORT.
Women and cats will do as they please, and men and dogs should relax and get used to the idea.
My therapist asked me if other members of my family suffer from mental health. I told him "No we all seem to enjoy it!"
Bronko22000- Posts : 372
Join date : 2022-01-20
Age : 69
Location : Locust Gap, PA
Re: Alloy or pure lead
“Another option is to cast pure lead then lube the bullets for the revolver and powder coat the ones for the 45 ACP.”
I think you’re on the right track, with this idea. I would DEFINITELY recommend pure lead for the revolver.
If you’re loading “on the revolver” vs. using a separate cylinder loading tool, you can potentially bend the loading lever!
Using overly large balls, or anything harder than pure lead, tends to increase this possibility.
***There have been some reports of folks bending the loading levers on their revolvers, even with the Ruger Old Army.*** I suspect that the lead must have been way too hard, as well as possibly oversized balls.
The ROA revolvers are discontinued, and parts like the loading lever are scarce!
I think you’re on the right track, with this idea. I would DEFINITELY recommend pure lead for the revolver.
If you’re loading “on the revolver” vs. using a separate cylinder loading tool, you can potentially bend the loading lever!

Using overly large balls, or anything harder than pure lead, tends to increase this possibility.
***There have been some reports of folks bending the loading levers on their revolvers, even with the Ruger Old Army.*** I suspect that the lead must have been way too hard, as well as possibly oversized balls.
The ROA revolvers are discontinued, and parts like the loading lever are scarce!
Jitterbug- Posts : 13
Join date : 2022-02-11
Bronko22000 likes this post
Re: Alloy or pure lead
Pure lead and 454 balls in mine. You want a snug fit and 451 or 452 conicals should work. I'd always go bigger on balls than conicals.
Gunpa- Posts : 8
Join date : 2022-04-08
deerstalkert likes this post
WELCOME to Idaho Lewis’s Muzzleloading Forum :: Muzzleloading, Firearms & Optics :: Black Powder Pistols
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|